Editorial team ·

Build a one-page source record that someone else can check

Editorial cover: Build a one-page source record that someone else can check
AI-generated illustration.

The draft has six claims and a folder with ten PDFs. A reviewer asks where the third sentence came from. Give each claim one row with a link or precise reference, the place to look inside it, and what the source leaves open.

Keep the record short enough to review

  1. Give each check a row
    • Record title, location and edition.
    • Add the exact supporting table or passage.
  2. Test it against the text
    • Read the claim with its limitation.
    • Follow the link or reference before publication.

Write the exact claim in the first column

In the fictional ledger, one row says 400 entries were recorded at the site. Its reference names the report, edition and table. A note says the count includes repeat entries. The reviewer can verify the wording without opening every file.

For qualitative claims, record the relevant item too. A view raised at a meeting can point to an agenda item or summary section. Give the source and date rather than relying on a link to an entire portal.

Add a status for things that are still open. “Check revised table” is useful. Label unsupported assumptions so they do not migrate into the published article as facts.

Read the rows alongside the draft before release. If the editor changes “entries” to “people,” fix the wording or find different evidence. The ledger is valuable because it exposes that change.

One-page record for three invented claims
Claim Exact source Limit or status
400 entries recorded Activity report, May edition, Table 2 Includes repeat entries
Access raised at meeting Meeting summary, item 3 A discussion topic, not a decision
Hours changed Dated venue notice Confirm start date of change

Questions and answers

Do I need one row for every sentence?
Use rows for material factual claims and any disputed point.
Should a source appear more than once?
Yes, when it supports several claims. Give the exact part that supports each.
What if the source disagrees with the draft?
Revise the claim to match the evidence or leave it open.